Freeze, Fawn (Appease), Tend and
Befriend
To
prevent, escape, or try to improve painful and traumatic abuse and neglect
suffered growing up we developed survival techniques, defense mechanisms, and
coping skills of fight, flight, freeze, or appease. We sought control in an out
of control world and learned to fear close relationships.
Even the normal ups and downs of relationships remind us of problems we had
earlier in life, so often trigger upsetting and painful memories.
Early man used these responses when
faced with real dangers, but modern man is under so much stress from so many
directions even common everyday situations like traffic can feel very
threatening. We may use many or all of coping skills these over time, but those
exposed to significant neglect or abuse become fixated on one or more of the
responses until they become deeply ingrained reactions, so over use them when there is no real threat.
The fight individual avoids intimate
relationships by becoming enraged and demanding. This is an unconscious drive
to alienate others so that intimate relationships and the resulting
vulnerability and risk of rejection are avoided. The fight reaction can manifest simply as denial and
resistance or escalate into actual verbal or physical confrontation and attack
that feels necessary to defend our sense of self and identity. These
people are often volatile with a short fuse or hair trigger.
The flight
response finds us running away to our rooms, schools, friends, or other people
and places that felt safe or welcoming, even if dysfunctional and dangerous
like gangs and bars. We also ran away into our heads; "the dark cave of
rumination" to escape difficult people and situations.
The flight response avoids close relationships by being distant or immersed in
activities like work, sports, or other addictions to shield us from
vulnerability and intimacy.
Freezing
up means shutting down and closing up, as our bodies and thinking became hard,
tight, and rigid. We may have attempted to relax or numb out through drugs and
other distractions such as obsessive compulsive exercise, work, or other
endeavors. "Freezers" avoid by not
participating socially, isolating, and taking refuge in fantasies and
daydreams.
Appeasing
is considered a relationship addiction as we form and maintain one-sided or
abusive co-dependent relationships. Appeasers attempt submission and people
pleasing as a way of winning others attention, approval, and love. Fawners
go out of their way to help others in a codependent dance to serve others, but
at a loss of their own sense of self.
Although
these states were very useful for surviving jungles and savannahs they are
problematic in modern life as they create a negative bias to remain vigilant
for threats. This fosters a negative mindset and focus on negative stimulus.
Even neutral situations are colored as negative or threatening and positive
stimulus (faces, words, etc) are missed or ignored.
The
fight or flight modes were identified over a hundred years ago, freeze and
appease came much later. A new pattern has been identified called "Tend
and Befriend". This is supposedly the female approach versus male for the
others. There is of course much controversy over the gender aspects.
The benefit of this mode is to protect offspring (tend) and rally others in the social circle for comfort and protection (befriend). The downside is this leads to tribalism as outsiders are avoided or shunned.
The benefit of this mode is to protect offspring (tend) and rally others in the social circle for comfort and protection (befriend). The downside is this leads to tribalism as outsiders are avoided or shunned.
We
come to favor one or two of these patterns, yet may cycle through them all at
one time or another.
All these patterns can be helped but are not considered curable so we are wise to recognize them in ourselves, work to overcome them, and be proactive to avoid them. Many were set deeply early on perhaps even before we could even speak, so accessing and overcoming them can be very difficult.
It
would be easy to consider these as character defects to be rid of, but are
defense mechanisms and survival tools that helped keep us safe and functioning,
so we actually owe a debt of to gratitude to them as they have served us well
many times. Through awareness, focus, and understanding we gain the wisdom to
transform them into useful tools and integrate them into our lives
beneficially.
The
impact on our beliefs, behaviors, and bodies is also influenced chemically when
these responses are triggered. As much as we can appreciate the
image of the heart a center of feelings and ascribe emotions to it the mind is
intimately connected to them as well. Beneficial chemicals such as dopamine,
oxytocin, and serotonin, as well as potentially problematic ones such as
cortisol and adrenaline come from deep within our brains and have a huge effect
on our emotions and well being.
Certain areas of the brain light up with loving thoughts to
produce and distribute dopamine to the brain, so it is considered the pleasure
drug. It also signals to us the importance of things thus mediating desire and
motivation, so it could also be called the desire drug. Anticipation of
rewards increases dopamine in the brain just like addictive drugs, so this
helps explain why we are sometimes so obsessed with love and desire.
Oxytocin is considered the love hormone (for women in
particular) as it assists in bonding with their offspring and mates. It also
enhances trust, generosity, pleasure, joy, empathy, and reduces depression,
fear, and anxiety for men and women. Testosterone inhibits oxytocin effects in
men, perhaps so they would not feel the pain and suffering of the game they
hunt and enemies they fight. The gender aspect
indicates men must make extra efforts to elicit and maintain their love
and oxytocin flows.
Human love also lights up areas in the brain that produce
serotonin, a calming chemical thought to be a contributor to feelings of
well-being and happiness. It is also associated with good mood, memory
processing, sleep, and cognition. Serotonin and well being are activated when
we hug and hold others, and not only people, but our cats, dogs, and other pets
and animal friends.
Cortisol and
adrenaline are produced in response to trauma or stress and gives us the energy
and focus for fight or flight response. These can also induced by caffeine,
sleep deprivation, intense exercise, and heavy drinking. These are so
ubiquitous in us they can be measured in our blood, saliva, urine, hair,
or feces. The flood of cortisol and adrenaline is fine in the short-term to
avoid and deal with threats, but over the long term cause mood disorders,
anxiety, depression, stress, illness, fear, and pain. These can be reduced by
music, massage, laughter, dancing, and magnesium supplements.
The
mind is an electro-chemical organ so is not just operating chemically, but on
various levels of brain wave electrical activity as well. The highest is Beta,
the alert, aroused, actively engaged
working state of mind. Alpha is more relaxed, restful, calm, and
reflective state. Theta is the drowsy, day dreaming state of imagination and
inspiration. Delta takes us into sleep as the deepest and dreamless state below consciousness. Perhaps
it is here we meet and join the oneness of universal consciousness.
There are two
nervous systems working within us: the activating and alerting sympathetic
nervous system triggered by adrenaline and cortisol, and the calming and
restoring parasympathetic nervous system of dopamine, oxytocin, and serotonin.
Arousal of these systems can be due to hereditary factors as well as become
habitual to environmental factors.
The
importance of this awareness is to recognize how much time we spend in each
state mentally and physically. Type A high achievers likely spend a lot of time
in beta mind states. Those in fight and flight etc. modes also obviously
trigger aroused alert states, but when you look at the downside of the
chemicals released and their detrimental
long term effects it becomes apparent how important a balanced heart, mind, and
life really are.
When
we look at people such as meditators who spend a lot of time in the lower wave
states we see much peace, calm, and confidence. It is easy to consider these
people as less important than high profile "movers and shakers", but the
Dalai Lama, Ghandi, and many other spiritual/religious figures show how
powerful and influential contemplative persons can be.
Another
Shorter Take on Fight or Flight Response:
When
early peoples faced threats they eventually retreated to their caves for rest
and safety. We are wise to do the same and make "caves" of comfort,
safety, and rest. Under threat we breathe fast and shallow and our heart beats
fast. The blood rushes to our muscles and we may feel faint, weak, and nervous.
Our brain scans for danger and thinks negatively. We get tunnel vision and
don't hear well so lose the big picture.
Our
minds close in too. Over time frequent stress, depression, and anxiety conspire
to sensitize us to further fight or flight reactions making it harder to
recognize and reduce the effects. The amygdala secretes hormones like adrenaline, cortisol, and others to the body in response
to perceived threats. In our busy, crowded, noisy, live we spend way too much
time in these stress response modes.
Cortisol,
adrenaline, and others work together to cause a burst of alertness, energy, and
attention by cranking out glucose and speeding up the heart to deal with
threats real or imagined. This increases
arousal and vigilance and enhances memory retrieval and formation. With that
comes tunnel vision and hearing to focus on the danger. Yet
over time chronic stress also causes anxiety, restlessness, headaches, sleep
deprivation, fatigue, depression, immune system weakness, acid reflux, and lowered
metabolism. Over the long haul these lead to all kinds of illnesses and
diseases.
On
the other hand oxytocin, seratonin, and dopamine are the "feel good"
hormones and serve to increase bonding,
generosity, and empathy. These also help relieve depression, aid sleep,
and create trust. Relaxation, mental stability, and anxiety relief are also
benefits. The dark side is the trust is built mainly among group members so we
come to mistrust outsiders.
The
highest state is gamma waves. This is the hyper aware zone of super focus,
expanded consciousness, and sharp awareness and concentration of top musicians,
athletes, meditators and such. In this state of intense flow these masters are
able to remain calm and highly productive even in extreme or difficult situations.
For
the rest of us when we experience stress we go into an highly aroused and engaged
state of beta brain waves. People having
an intense discussion and reading or writing complicated information would
experience beta. This is also the range of the inner critical voice, and it
gets louder the higher into this range our minds go. In beta we are often in a
reactive state and running habitual mental scripts. Although beta activities
can increase concentration and learning, they also tend to reduce emotional
awareness and creativity, and cause mental and physical fatigue.
The
alpha range is the non aroused state where we hear the voice of intuition. The
intuitive voice and influence becomes
clearer and more profound the deeper and slower the mind becomes. Alpha is the
home of better concentration, learning, visualization, and imagination. Here we
may be in the flow of repetitious or monotonous tasks where we lose track of
time and our minds wander. This relaxed state of reflection allows us to feel
safe and free to explore creative possibilities unavailable under stress.
Theta
waves indicate deep meditation, daydreaming, and REM light sleep. This is
another area of powerful visualizations and profound creativity, inspirations,
and insights. It is the subconscious and primordial state of feelings and emotions
beyond words and explanations. Here one might feel a deep spiritual flow and
openness to oneness with life, all creation, and the infinite.
Delta
mind is unconscious, but very important for deep rest, sleep, healing, and
regeneration. Here perhaps we have let go of ego and personality and become
absorbed into universal power, presence, and wisdom. Unfortunately with the
multitude of stressors in modern life many people find it hard to shift out of
beta's intense, tiring, and reactive mind set.
In
the Star Trek series when the Enterprise was under attack Captain Kirk would
order "All power to shields!" Consciously or unconsciously we do the
same. We need rest and relaxation! Yet even on days off and vacations we carry
the "got to do everything" (and perfectly) mentality to the extreme.
Long,
slow, and deep breathing helps ground us and return to a calm state. Being
grounded in our body means feeling emotions and being aware of the present
moment experience.